Trade Offered....Advice

Baldie

Baldie

Member
Someone is offering me Miles Austin/CJ Spiller for Doug Martin/Steve Smith........ Does that sound fair? I feel like Martin is my stud.

My current receivers:
Megatron
S Smith
L Moore
Steve Johnson

My current RBs:
Mathews
Martin
Wells
Redman
R Brown - Pending to drop for Crabtree
 
Last edited by a moderator:
R

RLLD

Member
No friggin way, Martin is a stud, Miles is one hit away from being out for 6 weeks, martin alone is worth more than Austin, plugging Smith in there too was either an effort at distraction or a direct insult....
 
Baldie

Baldie

Member
Ooops...sorry guys....He's actually offering Austin and CJ Spiller.

The team he has looks stacked at RB. He currently has Peterson, Ridley, Charles, and Spiller. At WR he has White, D Thomas, Austin and LIttle.
 
R

Runnik's Hambones

Active Member
I don't see an upside here for you. Miles for Smith is basically just a 1 for 1, I don't necessarily have one player rated above the other. Martin for Spiller is a bit similar, but I have Martin just a bit ahead of Spiller because I believe Martin will get more touches, not because I think Martin is any better than Spiller. After Spiller's giant game on Sunday this guy is trying to sell high, but I don't really understand why he's trying to trade Spiller for another RB since he's stacked there.

Don't do this deal. If he wants Steve Smith (because I can't see why he'd really need Martin) perhaps try a counter offer in which you buff up a different position.
 
R

RLLD

Member
Runnik's Hambones said:
I don't see an upside here for you. Miles for Smith is basically just a 1 for 1, I don't necessarily have one player rated above the other. Martin for Spiller is a bit similar, but I have Martin just a bit ahead of Spiller because I believe Martin will get more touches, not because I think Martin is any better than Spiller. After Spiller's giant game on Sunday this guy is trying to sell high, but I don't really understand why he's trying to trade Spiller for another RB since he's stacked there.

Don't do this deal. If he wants Steve Smith (because I can't see why he'd really need Martin) perhaps try a counter offer in which you buff up a different position.
Click to expand...

What this guy is doing is trying to dump Spiller and Austin high. He apparently wants to upgrade to Martin and Smith, and thinks our friend here will bite on the week 1 performances due to their wow factor. But we already know that Austin is suspect, and Spiller is less likely to put up good weekly numbers than Martin is....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top