Trade Advice

[Skedar120]

During my draft on saturday, I ruined my friend's night by taking Randy Moss one pick before he could. His strategy was built around a Brady/Moss combo all season.

Anyway, this is the latest attempt to get me to give him back. He is offering Calvin Johnson and 1 player of my choosing (other than Brady) for Randy Moss. Here's a look at rosters to give you a general idea of where we both sit.

Me
QB: Jay Cutler, Matt Cassel
RB: Steven Jackson, Lendale White, Willie Parker, Fred Jackson
WR: Randy Moss, Vincent Jackson, TJ Houshmandzadeh, Jeremy Maclin, Nate Washington, Deion Branch
TE: John Carlson, Dustin Keller
DEF: Panthers, Bucs
K: John Kasay

Him
QB: Tom Brady, Jason Campbell
RB: Thomas Jones, Ryan Grant, Rashard Mendenhall, Jamal Lewis
WR: Calvin Johnson, Jerricho Cotchery, Derrick Mason, Laveraneus Coles, Josh Morgan, Johnnie-Lee Higgins, Chris Henry
TE: Greg Olsen, Mercedes Lewis
DEF: Bears
K: Robbie Gould

The only thing I can see that would improve my team is Thomas Jones, but is it worth it, or can you think of anything better?

 

[Phicinfan]

During my draft on saturday, I ruined my friend's night by taking Randy Moss one pick before he could. His strategy was built around a Brady/Moss combo all season.

Anyway, this is the latest attempt to get me to give him back. He is offering Calvin Johnson and 1 player of my choosing (other than Brady) for Randy Moss. Here's a look at rosters to give you a general idea of where we both sit.

Me
QB: Jay Cutler, Matt Cassel
RB: Steven Jackson, Lendale White, Willie Parker, Fred Jackson
WR: Randy Moss, Vincent Jackson, TJ Houshmandzadeh, Jeremy Maclin, Nate Washington, Deion Branch
TE: John Carlson, Dustin Keller
DEF: Panthers, Bucs
K: John Kasay

Him
QB: Tom Brady, Jason Campbell
RB: Thomas Jones, Ryan Grant, Rashard Mendenhall, Jamal Lewis
WR: Calvin Johnson, Jerricho Cotchery, Derrick Mason, Laveraneus Coles, Josh Morgan, Johnnie-Lee Higgins, Chris Henry
TE: Greg Olsen, Mercedes Lewis
DEF: Bears
K: Robbie Gould

The only thing I can see that would improve my team is Thomas Jones, but is it worth it, or can you think of anything better?

First, I don't think you lose that much in taking Calvin over Moss. I do know however I am in the minority here.

Looking at your team....rb is a concern. White is RBBC, so is Parker and F.Jackson. I am not a steven Jackson fan.

So you could do T.Jones and Calvin for Moss. You get two solid starters...for one. Not a bad deal.

 

[Skedar120]

First, I don't think you lose that much in taking Calvin over Moss. I do know however I am in the minority here.

Looking at your team....rb is a concern. White is RBBC, so is Parker and F.Jackson. I am not a steven Jackson fan.

So you could do T.Jones and Calvin for Moss. You get two solid starters...for one. Not a bad deal.

Similar to my thinking, but I would say that Moss holds a little more value than Johnson, and he thinks so too, which is why the 2-for-1 came up. Plus, robbing him of his #1 RB would make me a very happy person.

 

[Phicinfan]

Similar to my thinking, but I would say that Moss holds a little more value than Johnson, and he thinks so too, which is why the 2-for-1 came up. Plus, robbing him of his #1 RB would make me a very happy person.

:nod: :biglaugh:

 

[Runnik's Hambones]

Moss for CJ and either TJ or Grant seems like a win for you.

 

[cctekguy]

... or can you think of anything better?

Yeah.

The look on his face every time Moss scores a TD.

PRICELESS!

 

[WesDawg]

I'd take CJ and Grant, since that's his actual #1 RB.

 

[bigheck33]

Grant for sure

 

[bodey24]

I would take Calvin and T.Jones

 

[Orgazmo]

I'd take CJ and Grant, since that's his actual #1 RB.

:nod:

 

[Remote Controller]

I'd take CJ and Grant, since that's his actual #1 RB.

Without a doubt!

 

[mudloggerone]

I agree!