should i accepr this trade???

[jmp782]

Hey guys, just got a trade offer from my fantasy league. Guy want to give me brent celek, jeremy maclin, and terrell owens for kevin boss, steve breaston, and reggie wayne. What do you guys think? I also have tom brady at QB, addai, hightower, and barber for my RB rotation. Any thoughts?
Posted via Mobile Device

 

[aspera1163]

I would not do that deal strictly because of Reggie Wayne. Celek was high on everyone's list because of Kolb's inexperience. A lot of people thought he would default to the TE but since Vick has been in, Celek's stats arent as great as most people thought. Wayne will score more points than TO and Maclin combined especially now that Garcon and Gonzalez are both out.

 

[JackG1980]

Who do you have at WRs and TE? But so far its a no go. tell him to keep TO and Celek and throw someone else in.

 

[tmaschm]

I would not do that deal strictly because of Reggie Wayne. Celek was high on everyone's list because of Kolb's inexperience. A lot of people thought he would default to the TE but since Vick has been in, Celek's stats arent as great as most people thought. Wayne will score more points than TO and Maclin combined especially now that Garcon and Gonzalez are both out.

+1. Wayne is the dealbreaker. Seems like everyone who is trading these days wants something for nothing.

 

[jmp782]

yup

I agree with you all, just wanted some feedback. I am going to counter and see if I can get maclin, and another receiver, I may do it. he also has Randy Moss, Brandon Marshall, pierre thomas, and michael turner...what would a good counter offer be?

 

[jmp782]

maybe try and get maclin and marshall??