Jonathan Stewart or Jason Snelling

Trickster

Trickster

New Member
With both Deangelo Williams and Michael Turner most likely missing the game, would you start Jonathan Stewart vs the Giants or Jason Snelling vs Buffalo, almost dead last in rush defense
 
Sgt John

Sgt John

Sith Lord of T&A
First, Id like to point out just how bad its gotten when this is a serious choice.....

Go with Snelling.
 
Sgt John

Sgt John

Sith Lord of T&A
Stewarts achillies can go bad at anytime. Snelling gets a good start against a bad team.

If you really need the tie broke, ask the Line Up Doctor
 
Sgt John

Sgt John

Sith Lord of T&A
Really..... he had one bad game against the Bucs....other than those:

18, 23, 6, 19, and 8 points. This week he faces the 32nd ranked run defense in the lague.

Stewart faces the #7 rush defense in the league. Against defenses ranked in the top 15, Stewart had one good game against the Vikings. The Cardinals game was good for him also, but its the Cards, and we honestly just cant trust what that team will do from week to week.

The others were worth 8,4,3, and 2 points. However, making this situation even more cloudy is his overall performance is decent when he gets at least 15 touches.

To me, it comes down to playing the odds. The Giants NEED this win and will bring it for four quarters. They know Matt Moore isnt going to beat them in the air, so it makes it much easier to shut down Stewart, who comes in with injury issues as always.

Snelling is getting an audition to play more next year or more some place else. The Bills just arent that good.
 
Trickster

Trickster

New Member
Sgt John said:
Really..... he had one bad game against the Bucs....other than those:

18, 23, 6, 19, and 8 points. This week he faces the 32nd ranked run defense in the lague.

Stewart faces the #7 rush defense in the league. Against defenses ranked in the top 15, Stewart had one good game against the Vikings. The Cardinals game was good for him also, but its the Cards, and we honestly just cant trust what that team will do from week to week.

The others were worth 8,4,3, and 2 points. However, making this situation even more cloudy is his overall performance is decent when he gets at least 15 touches.

To me, it comes down to playing the odds. The Giants NEED this win and will bring it for four quarters. They know Matt Moore isnt going to beat them in the air, so it makes it much easier to shut down Stewart, who comes in with injury issues as always.

Snelling is getting an audition to play more next year or more some place else. The Bills just arent that good.
Click to expand...

I agree. Thanks.
 
Sgt John

Sgt John

Sith Lord of T&A
250,000 VBs to winner. PPR, 1 pt per 10 rush or recieving yards, 1 point for 25 passing yards, 6 pts for a TD, 2 points for a 2pt conversion. No negative points.
 
mudloggerone

mudloggerone

Outlaw
Administrator
I've only managed one TD in our title game today and only have Wayne and the Vikes defense remaining. I sucking big time.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top