A
Axe Elf
As a psychologist, I think you just threw people off with the way you presented your list of potential keepers. Most people don't read these questions thoroughly, they just skim and give a knee-jerk response. You had Rodgers at the top of the list, and Richardson buried down amongst your defensive players and backups. Now that they've had time to axually think about it, people are starting to realized that Richardson is the pick.
Ask the question again on another message board somewhere with the list like this and see what answers you get:
Trent Richardson - CLE
D Williams - CAR
Mark Ingram - ATL
Wes Welker - DEN
Vincent Jackson - TB
Greg Olsen - CAR
Torren Smith - BAL
London Fletcher - WSH
Aaron Rodgers - GB
Andrew Luck - IND
W Woodyard - DEN
Ask the question again on another message board somewhere with the list like this and see what answers you get:
Trent Richardson - CLE
D Williams - CAR
Mark Ingram - ATL
Wes Welker - DEN
Vincent Jackson - TB
Greg Olsen - CAR
Torren Smith - BAL
London Fletcher - WSH
Aaron Rodgers - GB
Andrew Luck - IND
W Woodyard - DEN