Greg Jennings for Jonathan Stewart Trade?

A

AP_ALL_DAY_28

New Member
With the team that I have already drafted would it be a good trade if I traded Jonathan Stewart for Greg Jennings?

I would lose some of my RB depth though.

AP_ALL_DAY_28 (ILive4TheFunk)
QB-Matt Schaub (Houston)
RB-Shonn Greene (New York Jets)
RB-Jonathan Stewart (Carolina)
RB/WR-Jahvid Best (Detroit)
WR-Brandon Marshall (Miami)
WR-Sidney Rice (Minnesota)
WR/TE-Dez Bryant (Dallas)
TE- JerMichael Finley (Green Bay)
D/ST-
K-

Bench
QB-Joe Flacco (Baltimore)
RB-Cadilac Williams (Tampa Bay)

Here's the other guys team so far,


Onyxmeths
QB-Phillip Rivers
RB-Pierre Thomas
RB-Ben Tate
RB/WR-Greg Jennings
WR-Reggie Wayne
WR-Roddy White
WR/TE-Marques Colston
TE-Tony Gonzalez
D/ST
K

Bench-CJ Spiller
Bench-Montario Hardesty
_________________
 
B

brtdud7

New Member
i dont think you should.

you already have good WRs in Marshall, Rice, and Dez. You only have 3 RBs on your roster.

keep what you have
 
Skedar120

Skedar120

Buccaneer Faithful
I would do it, and that flex spot is the big reason why. Yeah, you'll lose some depth at RB, but you'll have a pretty good #1 and 2 #2s in Best/Caddy.

The biggest downside I see is the bye week implications it brings to your table. You'll have some holes to fill in weeks 4 and 7

Week 4: Sidney Rice, Dez Bryant, Caddy are out
Week 7: Shonn Greene, Jahvid Best are out

My last question: is this a PPR league?
 
A

AP_ALL_DAY_28

New Member
OK, so Onyx doesn't want to trade Jennings for Stewart straight up.

Should I throw Dez into the trade?

AP_ALL_DAY_28 Gets
Greg Jennings
12th Rd

Onyx Gets
Jonathan Stewart

Would that even be smart?
 
A

AP_ALL_DAY_28

New Member
With my last two picks I drafted Johnny Knox & Darren Sproles.


AP_ALL_DAY_28 (ILive4TheFunk)
QB-Matt Schaub (Houston)
RB-Shonn Greene (New York Jets)
RB-Jonathan Stewart (Carolina)
RB/WR-Jahvid Best (Detroit)
WR-Brandon Marshall (Miami)
WR-Sidney Rice (Minnesota)
WR/TE-Dez Bryant (Dallas)
TE- JerMichael Finley (Green Bay)
D/ST-
K-

Bench
QB-Joe Flacco (Baltimore)
RB-Cadilac Williams (Tampa Bay)
RB-Darren Sproles (San Diego)
WR-Johnny Knox (Chicago)


This is the 2 trades Onyx has on the table for Jennings.



AP_ALL_DAY_28 Receives
Greg Jennings
CJ Spiller
13, or 14th Rd

Onyx Receives:
Jonathan Stewart
Johnny Knox
Cadilac Williams

and

PackFan Receives
Greg Jennings
CJ Spiller
15th Rd (147)

Onyx Receives:
Santana Moss
Felix Jones
Marion Barber


If I do make that trade I'll be very thin at RB, here's what my roster would look like.

AP_ALL_DAY_28 (ILive4TheFunk)
QB-Matt Schaub (Houston)
RB-Shonn Greene (New York Jets)
RB-Jahvid Best (Detroit)
RB/WR-Greg Jennings (Green Bay)
WR-Brandon Marshall (Miami)
WR-Sidney Rice (Minnesota)
WR/TE-Dez Bryant (Dallas)
TE- JerMichael Finley (Green Bay)
D/ST-
K-

Bench
QB-Joe Flacco (Baltimore)
RB-Darren Sproles (San Diego)

I'm also shopping Matt Schaub around for a decent RB, but not much interest right now.
 
A

AP_ALL_DAY_28

New Member
It turned out the guy didn't even want Caddy, this is his offer.

AP_ALL_DAY_28 Receives:
Greg Jennings
CJ Spiller
Braylon Edwards
14th Rd (134)


Onyx Receives:
Jonathan Stewart
Darren Sproles
Johnny Knox
Anthony Gonzalez


AP_ALL_DAY_28 (ILive4TheFunk)
QB-Matt Schaub (Houston)
RB-Shonn Greene (New York Jets)
RB-Jahvid Best (Detroit)
RB/WR-Greg Jennings (Green Bay)
WR-Brandon Marshall (Miami)
WR-Sidney Rice (Minnesota)
WR/TE-Dez Bryant (Dallas)
TE- JerMichael Finley (Green Bay)
D/ST-
K-

Bench
QB-Joe Flacco (Baltimore)
RB-Cadilac Williams (Tampa Bay)
RB-CJ Spiller (Buffalo)
WR-Braylon Edwards (New York)

Still a bad idea? :)
 
JackG1980

JackG1980

New Member
I would actually do that trade. CJ Spiller is higher in PPR Leagues and Edwards should give you some good game. I believe Stewart will be inconsistent. Jennings has a higher value then Stewart, Spiller has a higher value then Sproles, Edwards is equal or better value then Sproles. The 14th pick is the only one lower in value. Do this trade.
 
A

AP_ALL_DAY_28

New Member
JackG1980 said:
I would actually do that trade. CJ Spiller is higher in PPR Leagues and Edwards should give you some good game. I believe Stewart will be inconsistent. Jennings has a higher value then Stewart, Spiller has a higher value then Sproles, Edwards is equal or better value then Sproles. The 14th pick is the only one lower in value. Do this trade.
Click to expand...

Ya but the problem is I would be very think at RB.

Best would be my #2 RB, and I'd only have 2 RBs on my bench (Caddy & Spiller).
 
JackG1980

JackG1980

New Member
AP_ALL_DAY_28 said:
Ya but the problem is I would be very think at RB.

Best would be my #2 RB, and I'd only have 2 RBs on my bench (Caddy & Spiller).
Click to expand...

Caddy, Spiller and Best all have a very good chance of being good RB2's... Plus you could put Rice, Jennings, and Marshall all on the trading block. Any one of those should land you a good RB1... You could afford to lose one of those easily. You have plenty of time to make a trade. I say you could get either; J. Charles, R. Grant, P. Thomas, Mendenhall, R. Mathrews, McCoy, Benson, D. Williams or B. Wells straight up for one of your receivers. Just put a note out to the league asking for a straight up trade for one of your WR1s for any of this RB1s. Then just wait and see what you get. Any of those RB have a higher value then J. Stewart in my opinion.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top