George Blanda - 418 yards 7 TDs 1 INT 7 XPs - 72.90 points
YA Tittle - 505 yds 7 TDs - 72.25 points
Sid Luckman - 443 yards 7 TDs 1 INT- 67.15 points
Michael Vick - 333 yards 4 TDs 80 rush yards 2 TDs - 65.65 points
Luckman may have had defensive stats that game putting him at #1, but I cant find a full box score from the game.
Ernie Nevers scored 40 on the field points in one game, and NFL record, but that was in 1929 and no record can be found of his yardage.
Michael Vick put on the greatest fantasy performance of the modern era, and as you can see, one of the best of all time. You witnessed history tonight.