Ive always felt that fantasy football is played completely backwards. The head to head matchups turns a game of strategy into a luck fest in a lot of cases.
I feel that fantasy football should be awarding a win to the top half of the league in scoring each week, while the bottom half gets a loss. It's not really round robin scoring, but its similar.
Far too often I've seen one of the best teams in the league draw the worst schedule possible and miss out on the playoffs. It's a flipping joke! On the other side, somehow a junk team gets a cake schedule and finds themselves stealing an unwarranted playoff appearance that should have gone elsewhere.
I never get anywhere with this argument though. People love their head to head matchups. They claim that this game we play should be played just like a football game...2 teams enter the gridiron, 1 team leaves. Unfortunately, it's impossible to make these 2 things alike. Fact is, there is nothing you can do to play defense against your opponent. No amount of strategy can hold your opponent to a 72 point output.
Another argument is that each week would be boring if you were only playing to get into the top half of your league, and that it's only fun when you get to go heads up with someone else. Is it really though? Look at your league scoreboard every week. How many games really come down to the last few minutes of MNF? Not nearly as many as you would think. In fact, most matchups have very little intrigued left over, with the winner being all but declared at the end of Sunday night.
For example, these are the scores from my 2 favorite leagues this week.
124-66, 109-87, 95-79, 77-62, 110-50, 125-84, 108-67, 80.5-46.5, 83-59.5, 132-66.5, 113.5-59.5, 122.5-93.5, 124-70
There's not a single game in those 13 matchups that had any intrigued left for MNF. It doesn't get anymore boring than that. How much more interesting would it be though if you owned the score of 79, sitting at 7th in scoring for the week, on the fringe of getting a win, but the team with 77 points was breathing down your neck? This will happen EVERY SINGLE WEEK.
Anyways.....that's my rant.