Trade offer, opinions please

N

Nafstejyn

New Member
.5 PPR, 6 pt TD's

My starters:
Mike Vick, AP, Arian Foster, Ryan Torain (RB/WR Flex), Reggie Wayne, Roddy White, Zach Miller (Oak)

Bench:
Stafford, DJax, Deion Branch, Derrick Ward, Toby Gerhart

I've been offered Drew Brees and Marques Colston for Vick/DJax...

I don't the offer as it is, but am thinking of countering (he's got Randy Moss) with Brees/Moss for Vick/DJax. Am I crazy or is that a good counter offer?

THX
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don't know about Moss' value right now. Favre has 2 fractures in his ankle. I don't know if he will be starting, and if he does start, his value is down. Moss is good and playing for a new contract. But he is in a new system and you saw that they are not on the same page yet. I would take Brees and Colston. Even though Colston is inconsistent, he will be on your bench. Brees is an elite QB, and NO will be getting better once Bush comes back. Philly is hurting and Andy Reid will go with the hot hand. Be it Vick or Kolb.
 
I accept this trade the way it is. If i can pull off the counter, I would rather have that though.

I dont care who is throwing to Moss, its MOSS! Only Randy Moss could have 5 TDs in 7 games, 2 TDs in 3 games in Minny, and people are complaining! If this is him "struggling" in a new system, DEAR LORD!!! :scared:
 
really the WR doesnt matter, you can take Moss or Colston and your bench will be fine....it comes down to which you'd rather have between Vick/Brees....Brees is probably safer, but Vick healthy has the potential to be better overall.....i probably do the deal and get the sure thing.....
 
i dont believe theres a debate here. You take Brees. A slow start so far, and perhaps he doesnt have the monster year weve come to expect but try to find a year where vick was a consistent decent fantasy qb. seriously. take brees before dude wakes up
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top