I have Steve Smith from Carolina, thinking about trading him for D. Jackson as I have Mcnabb and I like having WR/QB combo. Do you think this is a good trade or do you think I should hold on to Smith. I have Deangelo Williams at RB and I dont like having a Rb/WR combo on the same team.
Steve Smith (Carolina) for D. Jackson
- Thread starter johst16
- Start date
Cooley Cadets
Banned
My initial impression is that this may be a good time to trade Smith in a dynasty format.
Cooley Cadets
Banned
In a non-keeper it does not sound quite as compelling.
At this point I like the overall situation in Philly more than Carolina. Delhomme should still be able to pull things together to some extent but I am more intrigued by the QB situation in Philadelphia. McNabb is still one of the best, Kolb has done well in his limited opportunity and Vick is a sweet #3 for an NFL roster. Not sure if the appeal of the QB position is enough to offset the fact that Smith is THE guy in Carolina where Jackson has some nice options other than just him in the receiving department.
This comes down to preference and I don't think you take a big hit or get a huge uptick in production with either decision. If you do not like the RB/WR combo and do like the QB/WR then that could be the deciding factor.
At this point I like the overall situation in Philly more than Carolina. Delhomme should still be able to pull things together to some extent but I am more intrigued by the QB situation in Philadelphia. McNabb is still one of the best, Kolb has done well in his limited opportunity and Vick is a sweet #3 for an NFL roster. Not sure if the appeal of the QB position is enough to offset the fact that Smith is THE guy in Carolina where Jackson has some nice options other than just him in the receiving department.
This comes down to preference and I don't think you take a big hit or get a huge uptick in production with either decision. If you do not like the RB/WR combo and do like the QB/WR then that could be the deciding factor.
#1bears fan
New Member
I think you have to ride out Smith a little longer or trade for someone better than Jackson.