Rate These Rookies

[derringer007]

Just want your thoughts on these 2010 rookies, impact could be immediate, down the road, or not this season.

RB's Ben Tate (Hou), Joe McKnight (NYJ), and Deji Karim (Jac)

WR's Damian Williams (Tenn), Taylor Price (NE), Jordan Shipley (Cincy)

 

[Phicinfan]

Just want your thoughts on these 2010 rookies, impact could be immediate, down the road, or not this season.

RB's Ben Tate (Hou), Joe McKnight (NYJ), and Deji Karim (Jac)

WR's Damian Williams (Tenn), Taylor Price (NE), Jordan Shipley (Cincy)

Shipley has the lead right now as cincy's #3 wr. With him in the slot, and Ocho Cinco and Bryant on the outside..he could do well. Plus, I think he will be the long time replacement once Ocho's contract expires.

I have heard good things on Karim. They like him to eventually take the Fred Taylor role.

Tate should eventually beat out Arian Foster.

Not heard much on McKnight or Williams

 

[storminn0rm]

Shipley and Tate should have immediate impact this year.