Making a trade...

[JackG1980]

I believe Im getting a steal big time. I offered Flacco and Holmes for C. Johnson and M. Cassel and the guy said he will go it. I sent the trade proposal immediately. We are in a start 2 quarterback league, I already have T. Brady and A. Rodges. My Wrs are G. Jennings, Colston, Marshall, Holmes, and S. Moss. This is a PPR 8 team league. What do you all think if this trade.

 

[The Ram]

Are we talking Calvin Johnson?

 

[Miller]

if this is Calvin as I suspect, hell yeah I do this.

 

[The Ram]

if this is Calvin as I suspect, hell yeah I do this.

I agree with the glue sniffer, here. :banana:

 

[Deacon]

Based on your current lineup you should do this trade. You are not really losing anything with the 2 QBs you have. Barring injury you probably will never start Flacco over those 2 studs you have at QB.

Plus you are getting a quality RB which based on the other players you listed, you probably need.

 

[JackG1980]

Based on your current lineup you should do this trade. You are not really losing anything with the 2 QBs you have. Barring injury you probably will never start Flacco over those 2 studs you have at QB.

Plus you are getting a quality RB which based on the other players you listed, you probably need.

I meant to say Calvin Johnson... But I wil do it for Chris Johnson also.

 

[JackG1980]

The deal is accepted it just have to be voted on. Is it right to vote down a trade just because you dont like it? Or is it there specifically to prevent cheating?

My WR core is now stacked even for an 8 team league.

C. Johnson
G. Jennings
M. Colston
B. Marshall
S. Moss

Rest of team. QB (start 2) T. Brady, A. Rodgers, D. Garrard, M. Cassel
RBs K. Smith, R. Rice, J. Stewart, M. Lynch, Caddilac
TE J. Witten
Def Green Bay

 

[Deacon]

The deal is accepted it just have to be voted on. Is it right to vote down a trade just because you dont like it? Or is it there specifically to prevent cheating?

My WR core is now stacked even for an 8 team league.

C. Johnson
G. Jennings
M. Colston
B. Marshall
S. Moss

Rest of team. QB (start 2) T. Brady, A. Rodgers, D. Garrard, M. Cassel
RBs K. Smith, R. Rice, J. Stewart, M. Lynch, Caddilac
TE J. Witten
Def Green Bay

For an 8 team league those are some pretty pedestrian RBs though. I suspect you will need to package a couple of those WRs and get a true RB1 before its all said and done. Would have been a better trade if it was CJ 4.24.

 

[GZ2525]

The deal is accepted it just have to be voted on. Is it right to vote down a trade just because you dont like it? Or is it there specifically to prevent cheating?

My WR core is now stacked even for an 8 team league.

C. Johnson
G. Jennings
M. Colston
B. Marshall
S. Moss

Rest of team. QB (start 2) T. Brady, A. Rodgers, D. Garrard, M. Cassel
RBs K. Smith, R. Rice, J. Stewart, M. Lynch, Caddilac
TE J. Witten
Def Green Bay

People should never vote down trades unless it's collusion. People think they know what is going to happen and they don't. I changed it in my league so that it's all LM decision so people have to make legitimate cases to me if they wont a trade revoked.

 

[mudloggerone]

In my league I have stated to the other owners that I'm not here to protect someone from being stoopid, I only veto a trade if I feel they are cheating. That's never happened.

 

[JackG1980]

In my league I have stated to the other owners that I'm not here to protect someone from being stoopid, I only veto a trade if I feel they are cheating. That's never happened.

I agree... its just one guy in my league wants to vote it down just because he thinks im getting a better deal. I tried to explain to him thats not what its there for. He doesnt understand. Some people are saying its Holmes breakout year and could surpass C.J. in points. And Flacco is an upgrade to Cassel. I wouldnt be surprise if Flacco and Holmes outscore Cassel and C.J. Its just I think C. J. would be the more consistent option. Stafford does have an arm to reach him deep and I have a feeling they will be doing that often. Although he had 3 rec with 90 yards he was targeted 12 times. I have a feeling he will be targeted in the double digits probably every game. If he just catches one I have my points.

 

[JackG1980]

For an 8 team league those are some pretty pedestrian RBs though. I suspect you will need to package a couple of those WRs and get a true RB1 before its all said and done. Would have been a better trade if it was CJ 4.24.

Im already am... I tied Colston and K. Smith for Westy but it was a no go. I didnt get a RB till the 6th round. LOL. I went QB QB WR WR TE WR then RB. Our league is a little QB heavy and is PPR. We start 2 QBs and get 6 points a TD. So far I killed the first week with a 59 point margin.