Leinart or Henne?

[mills]

So I have 2 solid QBs for my starters and I want to pick up a QB to sit on the bench for a while. Matt Leinart and Chad Henne are sitting on the bench, which I think both will have good careers once they get the starting job. My question is which should I pick up. We are only allowed 3 QBs. My starters are Jay Cutler and Matt Hasselbeck.

 

[Coachnorm]

Hard to say as this is a bit of a close call here. Leinart might have more immediate value But I myself am a big Henne fan.

 

[tblGoBlue]

I would go with Henne he's got more upside... Leinart had his chance and it looks like he's never going to be a star. Besides, Henne is a Michigan alum so he's better than a SouthernCal pretty boy

 

[bodey24]

I would go with Leinart. Warner has never played full seasons back to back. Therefore Leinart may get another chance this season to step in and prove he can be the QB for the Cardinals.

 

[Jvirtue55]

Has Penington ever gone two full season?

 

[mills]

There's a lot of praise out of the dolphins camp on Henne. The QB coah has a lot of good things to say about him.

 

[WesDawg]

Henne is the better long term guy. But Cutler's only like 26 so hopefully you won't have to worry about it anytime soon.

Leinart's already had 2 unopposed opportunities at a starting gig and spit the bit both times. Which is inexcusable given the studs he has to throw to.

 

[Phicinfan]

I lean Henne here. Regardless of the senseless uncivilized mutterings of that negligent Michigan fan ( yeah..I am an Ohio State grad.....), he is correct.

First, Henne is the Qb of the future in Miami. Rumors abound that he will take over this year at some point.

What others have said are true too....Warner won't make it through the year..IMO, however, leinart has already shown he won't fit that system....so while he too will start...i don't think he survives.

My suggestion would be Henne. However, if you start two Qbs...don't you need a bye replacement?