Kurt Warner.....HOF???

[Remote Controller]

I know it's been discussed often, but what do you think? I feel he should easily be considered a Hall of Famer. Nice article Warner Q&A: On Hall, sorry Cards, Fitz, QBs ... and dancing - NFL - CBSSports.com Football

 

[Sgt John]

He is a HOF guy. Two teams to the Super Bowl.

 

[Arctic Dawgs]

Yup, the whole story makes him worthy. Bagging groceries to league and SB MVPs

 

[Mike]

I say no. Put him in the hall of "really good", not the hall of fame. We can't put everybody in, probably need to take several out.

 

[Sgt John]

Didnt Da Idiot do a series on this once?

 

[Vicious_Machine]

I say No as well. This is what makes the NFL HoF so great, and the NHL a joke. He just did not do enough (probably timeline wise). I think it was like between 2002-2006 where he didnt even have 30 TDs (or some span of like 5 years where he left the Rams - had that 1 year in NY, and then was a backup in AZ)

 

[Miller]

This is VERY close to me, but I struggle with putting him in b/c of the void of anything worthwhile between the Rams and Cards late in his career. Basically ends up being a handful of really good years and a the rest he was a non-factor.

Warner is a hall of fame story, but not a hall of fame football player. Sorry Kurt, just going to miss my cut here.