Keeper Help - Brandon Jacobs or Calvin Johnson??

[Danlaff777]

Hey guys, need some advice...
I'm in an 8 team league, we get one keeper from last years roster each season.

Start 1QB/2RBS/2WRS/1 Flex RB or WR

Scoring is pretty standard, 6pts per rush/rec TD, NON ppr league, we do get a 5 PT bonus for 100 yards Rushing or Receiving.

My two keeper options are Brandon Jacobs or Calvin Johnson.

These guys are being kept by the 7 other guys:
D Williams, A Peterson, M J Drew, A Johnson, S Jackson, M Turner, G Jennings

I have the 4th pick in the 1st round after keepers, snake draft so i'll have the 13th pick overall as well.

I'm taking a RB in round 1, one of Tomlinson/Chris Johnson/Slaton or Gore at pick #4.

Should i keep Jacobs and go WR in round 2? Or keep Calvin Johnson and go RB/RB in rounds 1 and 2?

Thanks in advance!

 

[tblGoBlue]

I'd take Megatron here.

 

[bodey24]

Calvin Johnson

 

[ExperiencedRookie]

M E G A T R O N!!!

 

[Danlaff777]

I'm gonna play devils advocate here since everyone is picking Calvin Johnson...

The league has a flex RB/WR spot so alot of guys take 2-3 RBs in the first 3 rounds. If i keep Megatron it means an elite RB probably isn't falling to me in round 2. My team will proabably look like this after keepers and 3 rounds:

RB Chris Johnson (round 1)
RB Pierre Thomas (round 2)

WR Calvin Johnson (keeper)
WR A Boldin (round 3)

if i keep Jacobs my team will probably look like this:

RB Chris Johnson (round 1)
RB Brandon Jacobs (keeper)

WR Reggie Wayne (round 2)
WR A Boldin (round 3)

out of those options i think id rather have Jacobs/Wayne than P Thomas/Calvin Johnson - what do you guys think?

 

[Sgt John]

Megatron.

 

[bodey24]

I like the Pierre Thomas/ Calvin Johnson team better.

 

[Runnik's Hambones]

I'd go Thomas/Johnson all freaking day.

 

[Skedar120]

I agree with the 8-0 consensus, go keep Megatron.

 

[12gaugetimmy]

Gotta go Megatron