Greatest Player in your NFL history?

[Scout200]

Several people have a favorite player.. but who do you think is the greatest player in your NFL history?

 

[Orgazmo]

Man, that's tough. I mean what defines "greatest"?

 

[efactor]

I got to go with Rice. When the greatest at any position is discussed, there's not a lot of debate that Rice was the best WR ever.

LT was the greatest defensive player I ever saw. Totally dominant..................

 

[Remote Controller]

I never saw a player do what Sayers could do.

 

[Zach]

The only player I have ever seen make it so a defense had to play a completely different game was Randy Moss.

 

[Phicinfan]

Offense Barry Sanders. Regardless of what the defense did, or what the O-line was unable to do, he made spectacular play after spectacular play and made it look easy. With missing almost no time doing it. I don't remember a defense ever getting a square hit on him.

On Defense, i would split betweek LT and Reggie White. You simply could not stop either of them.

 

[derringer007]

#34 RB Walter "Sweetness" Payton

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TWDV71E4Les&feature=related

 

[Sgt John]

QB - Tom Brady - Sorry, but this guy can win 10 games with two stretch armstrong dolls at WR
RB - Barry Sanders - Flat out the best ever IMO, and a guy who I think would have broke 20,000 on the ground if he stuck around.
WR - Jerry Rice - This is a no brainer, best ever by far
TE - Tough one..but Id say Tony Gonzalez
OL - Bruce Matthews
DL - Reggie White
LB - Lawrence Taylor/Ray Lewis
DB - Jack Tatum

 

[Deacon]

QB - Tom Brady - Sorry, but this guy can win 10 games with two stretch armstrong dolls at WR
RB - Barry Sanders - Flat out the best ever IMO, and a guy who I think would have broke 20,000 on the ground if he stuck around.
WR - Jerry Rice - This is a no brainer, best ever by far
TE - Tough one..but Id say Tony Gonzalez
OL - Bruce Matthews
DL - Reggie White
LB - Lawrence Taylor/Ray Lewis
DB - Jack Tatum

I know this is opinion but seriously, you rank Jack Tatum above Rod Woodson, Deion Sanders or Ed Reed? Really? Tatum was rightly so a feared head hunter but the best?

 

[efactor]

I know this is opinion but seriously, you rank Jack Tatum above Rod Woodson, Deion Sanders or Ed Reed? Really? Tatum was rightly so a feared head hunter but the best?

Ronnie Lott?

 

[derringer007]

OK so im a little biased, if your talking CB's a couple if pretty good Cover Corners were #22 Mike Haynes & #37 Lester Hayes must be thrown in the mix.

Mike Haynes, DB at NFL.com

Lester Hayes, DB at NFL.com

 

[Sgt John]

I know this is opinion but seriously, you rank Jack Tatum above Rod Woodson, Deion Sanders or Ed Reed? Really? Tatum was rightly so a feared head hunter but the best?

Ed isnt done yet. I know Ray isnt either, but while we still have DBs around in Eds league, LBs like Ray may be a thing of the past.

Ronnie Lott was a killer for sure, but I just like what Tatum could do to a game.

 

[Scout200]

QB - Tom Brady - Sorry, but this guy can win 10 games with two stretch armstrong dolls at WR
RB - Barry Sanders - Flat out the best ever IMO, and a guy who I think would have broke 20,000 on the ground if he stuck around.
WR - Jerry Rice - This is a no brainer, best ever by far
TE - Tough one..but Id say Tony Gonzalez
OL - Bruce Matthews
DL - Reggie White
LB - Lawrence Taylor/Ray Lewis
DB - Jack Tatum

Awesome list!!

 

[catman]

Jim Brown, Dick Butkus.