evaluate a dynasty league trade

[deuce4321]

Team 1:
Brady, Tom NEP QB $12,100,000 2 3/4
Vick, Michael PHI QB 8 $900,000 3 2/4
Portis, Clinton WAS RB $8,600,000 3 3/5
Spiller, C.J. BUF RB - $2,762,500 4 1/4
Starks, James GBP RB $1,912,500 4 1/4
Turner, Michael ATL RB $6,670,000 1 3/3
Housh, T.J. SEA WR (P) $10,350,000 1 3/3
Johnson, Calvin DET WR $7,200,000 3 3/5
LaFell, Brandon CAR WR - $1,912,500 3 1/3
Sanders, Emmanuel PIT WR $765,000 4 1/4
Thomas, Demaryius DEN WR $2,550,000 4 1/4
Williams, Damian TEN WR $1,912,500 4 1/4
Celek, Brent PHI TE - $2,400,000 2 2/3
Graham, Shayne BAL PK - $385,000 1 2/2



Team 2:

McCoy, Colt CLE QB - $720,000 5 1/5
Stafford, Matthew DET QB $2,700,000 3 2/4
Tebow, Tim DEN QB - $1,800,000 5 1/5
Goodson, Mike CAR RB - $540,000 3 2/4
Greene, Shonn NYJ RB $2,700,000 4 2/5
Wells, Chris ARI RB - $2,925,000 4 2/5
Holmes, Santonio NYJ WR (O) - $7,000,000 3 3/5
Iglesias, Juaquin CHI WR $2,475,000 1 2/2
Jackson, Vincent SDC WR $8,640,000 3 2/4
Moss, Randy NEP WR - $11,000,000 3 3/5
Winslow, Kellen TBB TE (P) $5,000,000 3 3/5



I have eliminated Defensive players because it made things easier to see.

 

[deuce4321]

trade was Turner and Winslow for Greene and Celek.

Turner is on the last year of his deal, Celek 2nd year of 3. Green is on the 2nd year of 5 and Winslow on 3rd year of 5.

Turner has a 6.67 mil sal, Celek 2.4. Greene 2.7 and Winslow 5mil.

At first i thought this was a steal for team 1 but after looking into it, it seems like team 2 really won big on this deal. Granted Celek will be better then Winslow and cheaper but the fact that Turner is only a one year deal for 6.67 mil vs another 3 years of Greene at 2.7 mil makes me think that this is a runaway for team 2.
Who do you think got the better end of the deal?

 

[chrisslabaugh]

For just this year- team 1

For the rest of time- team 2