Dynasty Draft: Percy Harvin vs Jeremy Maclin vs Hakeem Nicks

[Sgt John]

You may only choose one. Give reasoning if possible.

For me, I go with Harvin. I like the emphasis on him, the ability to score from different positions on the field, and the lack of competition.

 

[storminn0rm]

I went Nicks. He's coming out of a pro style offense, he has better upside than harvin or maclin, Eli needs a big target to replace Plaxico.

 

[derringer007]

I like H.Nicks as well after watching a lot of impressive game film. Nicks is just what the doctor ordered for Manning and the G-Men.

 

[bodey24]

I am going with Nicks as well. I think he is in the best position. I thought about taking Harvin because of his skills, but since he hasn't shown that he can stay healthy I am going with Nicks.

 

[RUBBER DUCKIE]

Long term I like Maclin as a possible WR#1 with the Eagles. Short term Nicks, but I think he's a WR#2 when all is said and done. I think Harvin is either going to be a total bust or extremly streaky, so I put him third because I think he could have 4 great games, 4 ok games, 4 games he's invisable and 4 missed games due to injury a year.

 

[Remote Controller]

This being the year of who has the best gadjet, I throw my support to Harvin. The Vikes are the most desparate, and have the least amount of wr competiton. Maclin is in the best passing attack and is a very close 2nd. Nicks is the best long range regular Wr prospect but not this year. There are a glut of Wr's in NYG.

I mistakingly hit Maclin instaed of harvin in the poll.

 

[Sgt John]

I will move your vote to Harvin

 

[Runnik's Hambones]

While I like Nicks more than the other two recievers, and I believe he has the best chance longterm (therefore best option for the question above in dynasty drafts), I think that Maclin has the best chance at immediate success.