Draft Grade?

[numbrfor]

What do you guys think... 12 team non-PPR league... picked 12th, serpentine, 16 rounds:

QB: B. Roethlisberger, Backup: D. Gerrard
RBs: S. Jackson and K. Smith, Backups: K. Moreno, J. Lewis, R. Mendenhall
WRs: A. Johnson and M. Colston, Backups: B. Edwards, J. Cotchery, T. Holt
TE: A. Gates, Backup: T. Scheffler
K: J. Brown
DST: Redskins

 

[cctekguy]

QB = C

Both function in a run first offense. Roeth is hurt. Don't like either one for fantasy purpose.

RB = B+

If Jackson delivers you are set. Smith is a solid #2. Lewis a good bye week fill and Moreno could be great. There are others I would have taken before Mendenhall but they are all crap shoots.

WR = A

Plenty of depth

TE = A

You got one of the "big 4" and Scheffler could pay off too.

K & DST = F

..as in "Who gives a F..."

Overall, very nice team. A lot hinges on Jackson not being a dud.

 

[Phicinfan]

What do you guys think... 12 team non-PPR league... picked 12th, serpentine, 16 rounds:

QB: B. Roethlisberger, Backup: D. Gerrard

You may have an issue here. I don't think Ben will ever explode like he did 2 years ago....the offense just isn't run that way. Garrard i was high on with the Oline fixes they did...but last game he was almost killed...so now I am really leery. Might want to make a move here for a better option.:sweat:

RBs: S. Jackson and K. Smith, Backups: K. Moreno, J. Lewis, R. Mendenhall

On the surface...you are okay. I am not a Steven Jackson fan, nor do I think he ever gets back to what he was. But with Moreno (once healthy) and Mendenhall ( who I think takes over in Pitt soon) you should be fine. I expect alot out of K.Smith this year. J.Lewis may eventually get surplanted by J.Davis...keep an eye on that.:thumbsup:

WRs: A. Johnson and M. Colston, Backups: B. Edwards, J. Cotchery, T. Holt

Not bad at all. Colston if he can stay healthy should make a great pair with A.J. Edwards I think comes back this year...adn Cotchery is clearly the #1. Late grab of Holt could be a steal as well. Nice job here!:thrash:

TE: A. Gates, Backup: T. Scheffler

Very nice! Gates is healthy, and should be the #2 TE this year. I am very high on Scheffler..especially with the injuries at Rb, and Marshall being an idiot. You are solid here. :thumbsup:

K: J. Brown
DST: Redskins

Decent K but the D may be an issue. Might want to see if you can improve this some.:sweat:

Overall you are pretty solid. I do think you really need to make a move to improve at Qb. You have great depth at WR and Rb...so you should be able to make a deal with someone to snag a better option at Qb.

Good luck