Cutler or Cam? Who's worse?

[efactor]

Fantasy aside, who do you think is the worse real life QB?

Just curious what others think. Both are talented guys who display horrible body language when things are not going their way, which to me is a sign that they are terrible leaders.

Pretty much a tie for me, but I'll give the edge to Cam due to his selfishness. I really admire (sarcasm) how he does his Superman gig after a 2 yard gain for a first down. Was especially fond (sarcasm again) of how he did that against Seattle for a first and goal at the 3 and then was forced to kick a field goal. The guy is just plain clueless and I think he will always me a "me first" kind of player.

Cutler is a different kind of clueless. Seems like a team guy, but goes Tharn (think deer in headlights) when things get tough.

That's all

 

[jjtweeks]

I think Cutler is just a bit worse. Cutler is surrounded by studs. I agree Cam is selfish but if i was Cam and I played on that team I might be too.

 

[mudloggerone]

My thoughts exactly JJ for me it is Cutler though they both have been disappointing. Cutler has almost as many weapons as the air force and army combined but he still doesn't play anywhere near consistent ball.

 

[ExperiencedRookie]

I hate Cam Newton for all the reasons previously listed. My least favorite player in the NFL.

I'll try to put that bias aside for a second when I say that he's absolutely the worse player/leader/sideline crybaby of these 2.

 

[mudloggerone]

Come on ER don't hold back. Most of us are grown ups here.

 

[ExperiencedRookie]

Come on ER don't hold back. Most of us are grown ups here.

My hate probably comes from the fact that he was one of these pampered college douche bags who has experienced the highest level of hero worship that comes with the big stage of the Heisman etc etc. Too many people kissing his ass..and now that he's in the big leagues and sucks, he just mopes around with that towel on his head, waiting and wondering if anyone will worship him anymore.

 

[German CTL]

Cam looked absolutely pathetic in the Monday nighter. Not only did he appear to be gimpy after basically having a byeweek but he gave the impression that he couldnt care less about playing in that game, like he'd rather be watching from his couch. I figured for sure he'd be on this weeks injury report, but no! Was he acting hurt? Idk. Gimme Cutler, at least his frumpy appearance is entertaining while he's tanking and he seems to care a little more about the game.

 

[Phicinfan]

while I don't totally disagree with most here, I would argue Cam not having tools is getting harder to support. He has a solid young Wr in Benjamin and Olsen is a top three TE this year. Granted the O-line is killing him and the running game...but you can say that in Chicago as well.

I would rather not touch either, and have a journeyman like Orton til I could draft my future, but of the two, I would go Cam for his legs.

 

[mudloggerone]

Always knew you were a "leg" man PhiCin. ")

 

[jjtweeks]

Cutler has arguably the best pass catching back in the NFL

 

[Phicinfan]

Cutler has arguably the best pass catching back in the NFL

Cutler has the best tools of almost any team - with Forte, Jefferey and Marshall. No denying that.

but to me he is too hit or miss, at least Cam makes plays with legs when he can't hit the broad side of a barn.

 

[mudloggerone]

I think we might should throw RG III into this conversation and standing at the back of the crowd looking to be a part of this conversation is the 49ers golden child Kapernick. God I hate that guy.

 

[jjtweeks]

yea this is a good question and it is very close to me overall and so very different

 

[Phicinfan]

it was a similar conversation on ESPN radio this morning on Mike and Mike.

Choose who you want between Cutler, RG3 and E.Manning. You could add Cam in and Kaepernick as well. All are in about the same position this year. All have plus or minuses.

 

[mudloggerone]

I know that this is the last year I'll deal with Kap on my team.