Cam Newton vs. Robert Griffin III?

[knuckleballah22]

Just had a little debate with one of my buddies on the topic. I was split and said I'd take either... but he just loves Newton's abilities and believes that it's a no-brainer pick. Who would you take to lead your team?

Obviously Newton came out on top in their week 9 matchup but I still find it difficult to compare the two... Cam is in his dreaded sophmore slump, whereas RG3 is a rookie... but if I just had to I think I'd go with RG3. Redskins offense has completely come alive since he's arrived and he's so dang accurate. But like i said..I like Cam Newton too.

 

[jjtweeks]

Cam's head is so swollen from such a great rookie season which, between that and such horrible management in Carolina hurts him as a leader. Cam is not ready to be a team leader or try to carry the team by himself, both of which he tries to do often. RG knows his place a little better but has poor coaching but not nearly as bad as Carolina. I like both players but Carolina needs a more mature leader(and a better offensive scheme) and Cam just needs to play. Right now I would rather have RG just because of those things Cam struggles with. If Carolina and Cam had a handle on those issues it might be different for me.

 

[Phicinfan]

I tend to judge on ability, and offensive plan.

I really like RG3 over Cam for this reason. RG3 is a much better passer, and if they ever get him some really solid tools to work with, he will continue to grow. Cam is a bit of a head case, and if you can frustrate him early, he will implode. Also his tools(namely only Steve Smith) are aging.

In dynasty, I would much rather have RG3

 

[mudloggerone]

Agreed