It depends who you are playing with. You made a post:
"I give; Amendola and Moreno
I Get; Randy Moss and J. Stewart"
If I did that in any of my leagues, I would have to find another 10 new owners to play with if it was a 12 team league, cause the other 10 owners would kill me or consider the league a joke, but regardless, the two people involved in the trade would NOT be back next year.
Knowing the coach and the other regulars on this forum, no way on god's green earth he can even SEND an offer like that. He would be laughed at like no tomorrow! Now, if he's in a random yahoo league, he can probably offer up Peyton Hillis for Chris Johnson and it might work too, cause some people are just plain stupid!
Also, hindsight is 20/20! Are you saying if somebody drafted Collie over Ryan Grant at your draft, they were a genius??? I say, they were stupid, and got lucky! FF has a lot of luck involved, somebody who took Nicks over Steve Smith was probably mocked at draft time, but is a genius now!
As for Crabtree, I have always been PRO-CRABTREE all year (go check my posts), and I would never say Cribbs over Crabtree.
But all that is neither here nor there. In any legit or competitive league, your not getting any real value for Hillis (Like RC & Coach have mentioned), and I cannot imagine the coach is anything less then a way too competitive league! Thats why I always still their ideas