A Nice Dynasty Ranking

Remote Controller

Well-Known Member
Found this and wanted to share. We might not all agree with it, but it took some work and is a nice place to start one of our own here.


TOP 30 DYNASTY TEs:
Tier One
1. Jermichael Finley, Packers | Age: 23.6 – His emergence reflects the changing of the guard in TE Dynasty rankings . He’s a physical mismatch for linebackers and safeties, drawing comparisons to a young Tony Gonzalez. An incredible athlete, he was flat-out uncoverable at times late in the season. He also has the advantage of playing with the brightest young quarterback in the league.

2. Vernon Davis, 49ers | Age: 26.8 – Finally making good on his freakish talent, Davis was a playmaking monster all over the field.

3. Dallas Clark, Colts | Age: 31.3 – Clark's 100 receptions were the second-most in history for a tight end, behind only Tony Gonzalez’'s 102 in 2004. Having the confidence of Peyton Manning surely helps his cause.

4. Antonio Gates, Chargers | Age: 30.3 – After an injured-filled disappointing 2008, Gates returned to the elite player he was from 2004 through 2007. Though 2009 wasn't his best fantasy season due to a mediocre touchdown total, it was Gates' best NFL season.

5. Jason Witten, Cowboys | Age: 28.4 – You could make the argument that Witten is due for a healthy bounce-back in touchdowns next season, but he's had four TDs or less in three of the past four seasons. But he's still a lock for 85 catches and 900+ yards.

Tier Two
6. Brent Celek, Eagles | Age: 25.8 – Celek is improving as a blocker, and his speed and after-the-catch ability that sets him apart. He will remains a top option in the Philly passing game for years to come.

7. Kellen Winslow, Buccaneers | Age: 27.2 – Josh Freeman was surprisingly good for Winslow's value. He is now the focal point of the Bucs passing offense, though that could change if the Bucs can get a true No. 1 receiver.

8. Owen Daniels, Texans | Age: 27.10 – Daniels was basically used as the Texans' No. 2 receiver before he suffered the third ACL injury of his career. The injury ruins his chances of signing a monster contract, but he'll return to Gary Kubiak’s offense in 2010.

9. Tony Gonzalez, Falcons | Age: 34.7 – He’s proof that elite tight ends can maintain their skills a long time, but the all-time best NFL tight end of is another year closer to the end.

10. Dustin Keller, Jets | Age: 26.0 – Keller's playoff run illustrated solid hands, good route running, red-zone presence, and impressive after-the-catch ability. Although he can't run block on a team that prides itself on a "ground and pound" attack, his blocking can only get better, and so will his rookie QB.

Tier Three
11. Zack Miller, Raiders | Age: 24.9 – He’s a Top-5 if the Raiders give up on Russell and get a legit NFL passer. There is buy low potential.

12. Chris Cooley, Redskins | Age: 28.2 – A trade chip for Mike Shanahan? Fred Davis played well down the stretch, and the new regime might welcome more draft picks.

13. Greg Olsen, Bears | Age: 25.6 – The talent is there but he just didn't make the leap in 2009. Olsen would be screwed if Mike Martz lands the Bears offensive coordinator job.

14. Tony Scheffler, Broncos | Age: 27.7 - Still among the most effective pass-catching tight ends in the league, Scheffler was under-utilized in Josh McDaniels' offense. But don not sleep on the talented tight end coming out of a bad situation. Scheffler is expected to be dealt this offseason, and all he needs is the right situation to regain fantasy relevance.

15. Jared Cook, Titans | Age: 23.5 – The young freakishly talented receiver/tight end should see a dramatic increase in playing time in 2010.

16. Gary Barnidge, Panthers | Age: 25.0 - Barnidge has soft hands and 4.6 speed. He’s the second best receiving option on the team. Look for his role to increase in 2010.

17. Evan Moore, Browns | Age: 25.8 – A former basketball player and wide receiver at Stanford, Moore flashed soft hands and impressive athleticism down the stretch.

18. Heath Miller, Steelers | Age: 27.11 – Was 2009 the start of a trend or simply a career year?

19. John Carlson, Seahawks | Age: 26.4 – You can’t catch many passed if you ar almost always required to stay in to block. Lack of opportunity killed his 2009 fantasy value.

20. Brandon Pettigrew, Lions | Age: 25.7 – Just when he was starting to show promise, he tore his ACL. He could begin the 2010 season on the PUP list.

Tier Four
21. Zach Miller, Jaguars | Age: 25.11 – Miller is a former quarterback who flashed impressive speed and solid hands with a solid 15-catch December.

22. Fred Davis, Redskins | Age: 24.8 – Not on Cooley's level yet as an all-around player, but he's proven to be a more effective red-zone weapon. His fantasy value is entirely dependant on a Cooley trade.

23. Kevin Boss, Giants | Age: 26.8 – Boss most likely had a career season in 2010.

24. Visanthe Shiancoe, Vikings | Age: 30.3 - Shiancoe's value is highly dependent on the return of Brett Favre. Shiancoe is not much of an asset outside the red zone.

Tier Five
25. Martellus Bennett, Cowboys | Age: 23.6 – The ultra-talented second TE took a step back in 2009, even losing snaps to John Philips down the stretch in a penalty-filled season

26. David Thomas, Saints | Age: 27.2 – Thomas filled in beautifully down the stretch, but his fantasy value revolves around Shockey's health.

27. Ben Watson, Patriots | Age: 29.9 – Patriots are fully expected to let him walk. He's in dire need of a fresh start elsewhere.

28. Jeremy Shockey, Saints | Age: 30.1 – Constantly battling through nagging injuries, Shockey is a poor fantasy option. Wait for him to open the season strong, and then deal him before the injuries start to kick in.

29. Todd Heap, Ravens | Age: 30.6 – See Shockey's comments.

30. Shawn Nelson, Bills | Age: 24.11 – Nelson deserves a mulligan in the Bills' enemic offense.

TOP 80 DYNASTY WRs:

Tier One
1. Andre Johnson, Texans | Age: 29.2 – Everything you want in a Dynasty receiver except double digit touchdowns. Physically dominating opposing corners, Johnson gets open down field even against double coverage.

2. Larry Fitzgerald, Cardinals | Age: 27.0 – A lock for double digit touchdowns and 95+ receptions every season. Although a Warner retirement would hurt Fitz's value, but perhaps not as much as one would think. Fitz averaged 82.4 yards and 5.7 receptions in the seven games he and Matt Leinart played together during Leinart's rookie season. He's averaged 84.2 yards and 6.3 receptions in the games Warner has started the past five seasons. As long as he can get into the end zone at least 10 times per season, Fitzgerald will remain a fantasy stud.

3. DeSean Jackson, Eagles | Age: 23.9 - The best open-field wide receiver in the NFL? Giving Chris Johnson a run for his money as the most electrifying player in the league, Jackson has to be considered a top-tier Dynasty receiver due to his unique talent. The bottom line is he's always open and corners can't handle his speed.

4. Miles Austin, Cowboys | Age: 26.2 – With a career rate of one touchdown for every seven times he catches the ball, Austin rivals DeSean Jackson as the best after-the-catch receiver in the NFL. Only Andre Johnson scored more points once Austin hit the starting lineup, and Tony Romo’'s No. 1 receiver has potential to be a double-digit TD scorer for the next five-to-six seasons.

5. Calvin Johnson, Lions | Age: 25.0 – Calvin not only had to content with TRIPLE coverage, but his bout with a knee injury and the crippling performances of Drew Stanton and Duante Culpepper deflated his value in 2009. Calvin should be the number one dynasty target of the off season. Savvy fantasy owners will throw out an offer ASAP.

6. Vincent Jackson, Chargers | Age: 27.8 - The leap has been made. Already unstoppable on deep balls and in the red-zone heading into the season, V-Jax flashed signs that he can take over as a possession receiver as well. He's simply too big and too fast for even the best cover corners to contain.

7. Reggie Wayne, Colts | Age: 31.10 – Except for his age, he’d be ranked much higher. He has finished in the Top-6 in fantasy points in three of the past four seasons. With Manning as his QB, his productivity should continue for three years or perhaps more.

8. Roddy White, Falcons | Age: 28.10 – He is the first player in franchise history to record 80 catches and 1,100 yards in three consecutive seasons, White was a Top-7 fantasy receiver for the second straight year and Top-15 for the third straight. White has emerged as one of the best route runners in the NFL, and he's terrific after the catch.

Tier Two
9. Sidney Rice, Vikings | Age: 24.0 – Ranked with the who's who of elite receivers in fantasy points throughout 2009. Rice unquestionably has the talent to merit a higher ranking, but future quarterback uncertainties keep him out of the top tier.

10. Greg Jennings, Packers | Age: 27.0 – There's no question that his early-season woes were affected by the O-Line woes, forcing Aaron Rodgers to get rid of the ball before Jennings could streak down field. Jennings may not be quite as talented as some receivers listed lower, but Rodgers provides great value stability. He is another “buy low“.

11. Michael Crabtree, 49ers | Age: 23.0 - Part of San Fran's suddenly promising young offensive nucleus, Crabtree has already shown the total package as a No. 1 receiver.

12. Marques Colston, Saints | Age: 27.3 – Colston has an obscene catch radius, and Brees trusts him implicitly to come down with the ball in heavy traffic. But Meacham‘s second-half emergence led to a decrease in Colston's production. He caught more than five passes just twice in the second half of the season with Brees spreading the wealth.

13. Randy Moss, Patriots | Age: 33.7 – Pushing 34, he doesn't appear to be the dominant talent he once was. Moss can still take over a game, but he just disappears too often to maintain elite value as he ages.

14. Santonio Holmes, Steelers | Age: 26.6 - Would you believe he finished just 16 yards away from tying Reggie Wayne and Randy Moss in receiving yards? As Hines Ward begins to decline, Holmes' touchdown totals should rise.

15. Steve Smith, Giants | Age: 25.4 - Made the leap to true No. 1 receiver for the Giants in 2009, but Hakeem Nicks offers equal upside.

16. Hakeem Nicks, Giants | Age: 22.8 – Nicks had an inconsistent rookie campaign, but the important thing is that his size and homerun hitting ability make him a threat for double digit touchdowns as soon as next season. Already he succeeded in pushing Mario Manningham out of the starting line-up.

17. Percy Harvin, Vikings | Age: 22.3 - He is ranked this low only out of comcern with his debilitating migraine episodes. Harvin displayed better than expected strength and toughness to go with his impressive after-the-catch ability. Before the migraines, he was on pace for 64 receptions, 1,059 yards from scrimmage, and 11 total touchdowns.

18. Brandon Marshall, Broncos | Age: 26.6 - His talent and productivity is unquestioned.
If you're fine with the ongoing soap opera as your No. 1 receiver, feel free to move him up your personal rankings.

Tier Three
19. Steve Smith, Panthers | Age: 31.4 - If you throw out games started by Chris Weinke, 44-year-old Vinny Testaverde, and Delhomme’s 2009 implosion, Smiff has produced at the same rate since his career year in 2005. Matt Moore’s late-season progress bodes well.

20. Dwayne Bowe, Chiefs | Age: 26.0 - His work ethic was questioned throughout the Herman Edwards era, he spent the offseason in Todd Haley's doghouse, and then he was dealt a four-game suspension. There's at least a hint of knucklehead potential here.

21. Mike Sims-Walker, Jaguars | Age: 25.10 - After his mid-season hot streak, he finished as just the No. 67 fantasy receiver over the final five weeks. And whether MSW owners like it or not, the checkered injury history adversely affects his Dynasty value.

22. Robert Meachem, Saints | Age: 26.0 – Meachem has the pedigree, size, talent, and nose for the end zone to eventually emerge as a Top-15 Dynasty option. He has earned the starting job opposite Colston going forward, and he was as a Top-20 fantasy receiver over the second half of the season.

23. Mike Wallace, Steelers | Age: 24.1 – Wallace proved that he's more than just a speedster, hauling in clutch catches throughout the season. Already a borderline WR3, Wallace will see a value spike as Hines Ward’s completes hs decline.

24. Kenny Britt, Titans | Age: 22.0 - Undeniably the Titans' best receiver, Britt is a prototype No. 1 emerging as a deep threat as well as a go-to clutch option. He's already a fine WR3, and he could graduate to consensus Top-20 by next season.

25. Jeremy Maclin, Eagles | Age: 22.4 - We knew he could get deep, but he also made tough catches over the middle and against the sidelines.

26. Chad OchoCinco, Bengals | Age: 32.8 – Ocho had a fine comeback season, but he's hitting the downslope just as his quarterback loses his magic touch. Can "85" be counted on as a WR2 if Carson Palmer is still battling injuries or mechanical issues next season?

Tier Four
27. Anquan Boldin, Cardinals | Age: 29.11 – Never count on him to play a full 16-game season. It's tough to tell if he can't stay healthy enough to play at 100%. And after Early Doucet’s postseason performance, Arizona will likely part ways with Boldin. His next address will go a long way to determine Dynansty value.

28. Wes Welker, Patriots | Age: 29.4 – Welker is a tricky to player to rank after tearing his ACL and MCL. He's not likely to be back to full health until the middle of next season, and we're left to wonder how the reconstructive surgery will limit his main strengths of cutting, shiftiness, and elusiveness in the long-term.

29. Austin Collie, Colts | Age: 24.10 – The first-team all-rookie receiver earned Peyton Manning’s confidence from the start by being in the right place and catching everything thrown his way. Already a complete receiver with a dynamite work ethic.

30. Lee Evans, Bills | Age: 29.6 - Held hostage once again in Buffalo, this time by the offensive line as well as the rotten QB play. I'd buy low if I had any confidence in the Bills dramatically upgrading their trouble spots.

31. Steve Breaston, Cardinals | Age: 27.1 – Who benefits more from an Boldin trade: Breaston or Doucet?

32. Julius Edelman, Patriots | Age: 24.4 – If Wes Welker is tricky to rank, then Edelman is too. He gave a monstrous effort in the Pats' playoff loss, showing that he belongs at this level. He obviously fits best in the slot, but the Patriots need more of a down-field threat to complement Welker and Randy Moss. Since Welker won't be close to 100 percent next season, Edelman should have another window of opportunity to carve out a primary role.

33. Eddie Royal, Broncos | Age: 24.4 – Royal has plenty of talent, but he was nothing more than a skilled decoy in Josh McDaniels' offense. Will that change next season?

34. Pierre Garcon, Colts | Age: 24.1 - Garcon is making Anthony Gonzalez look like an afterthought. President Bill Polian, who hyped Garcon all offseason, has already called him "a run-after-the-catch threat that we've never had here."

35. Early Doucet, Cardinals | Age: 24.9 – This is the offseason the Cardinals will actually put a legitimate effort into an Anquan Boldin deal. Doucet's postseason performance showed a player who could step right into Boldin's role in the offense.

Tier Five
36. Braylon Edwards, Jets | Age: 27.7 - The Jets aren't expected to rush into a long-term deal with Edwards this offseason, which is no surprise considering he still isn't consistent catching the ball. Regardless, until the Jets get confidence in Sanchez’ arm and decision-making, their conservative run-oriented will limit his upside.

37. Santana Moss, Redskins | Age: 31.3 – He makes the perfect trade throw-in as a bounce-back candidate in Mike Shanahan’s offense.

38. Devin Hester, Bears | Age: 27.10 - Alternately ineffective and injured over the second half of the season, Hester was a potential No. 1 receiver in the season's first two months.

39. Jerricco Cotchery, Jets | Age: 28.3 – Cotchery is too pedestrian to be considered more than a low-end WR2, and the trade for Braylon Edwards was an indictment of Cotchery as a No. 1 receiver from the Jets point of view.

40. Anthony Gonzalez, Colts | Age: 26.0 – Like most Colts players, he derives more value from situation than talent. Now that Collie and Garcon have emerged, Gonzalez's situation has changed dramatically.

41. Jacoby Jones, Texans | Age: 26.2 - Jones makes at least one eye-opening play every week, and opposing teams couldn't keep him out of the end zone even in limited touches. Now more of a receiver as well as a returner, he’s ready to take over Kevin Walter‘s jpb.

42. Devin Thomas, Redskins | Age: 23.8 - Did the light finally flip on? Thomas exploded for 7-100-2 against the Saints as Sherm Lewis called his number late in the season.

43. James Jones, Packers | Age: 26.6 – Reminiscent of Anquan boldin in body type, strength, and after-the-catch ability, Jones is the best bet to succeed Donald Driver.

44. Bernard Berrian, Vikings | Age: 29.9 - Outperformed by Sidney Rice and Percy Harvin in a season lost to hamstring woes, there's at least a ray of hope for Berrian.

45. Joshua Cribbs, Cleveland Age - Nominally a WR, Cleveland’s most dangerous offensive threat is a man without a real position. He would rank much higher in leagues that count return yardage. Here’s hoping that the new Brown’s “brain trust” finds a way to get him 10 to 15 touches per game in addition to returns.

46. Laurent Robinson, Rams | Age: 25.4 - The Rams scouts know how to spot a talented receiver. Robinson is the real deal with ideal size and speed -- and a better all-around receiver than Avery. Like Avery, he has a hard time staying healthy.

Tier Six
47. Antonio Bryant, Buccaneers | Age: 29.6 – An unrestricted free agent this offseason, Bryant can put up good numbers in any given year but he's a poor bet for sustained value.

48. Roy Williams, Cowboys | Age: 28.9 - Just flat-out useless if Tony Romo isn't throwing him a bone in the red zone. Williams has already lost the No. 1 receiver job to Miles Austin, and it won't be long before he loses the other starting job as well.

49. Malcolm Floyd, Chargers | Age: 29.0 – A restricted free agent this offseason, the Bolts are unlikely to let their new No. 2 receiver get away. He remains behind V Jax and Gates, which puts a ceiling on his value.

50. Devin Aromashodu, Bears | Age: 26.4 - Nowhere close to Miles Austin’s talent level, but Jay Cutler likes throwing to him – which counts for quite a bit in Chicago. Let's see what the Bears do this offseason before going crazy over his value.

51. Johnny Knox, Bears | Age: 23.10 - Knox may have a brighter future than Devin Hester. There aren't many faster receivers in the league.

52. Jabar Gaffney, Broncos | Age: 29.9 – His value is wholly dependant on the Broncos' offseason moves.

53. Donny Avery, Rams | Age: 26.3 The smallish Avery simply can't stand up to the pounding. If he does manage to stay injury-free, Avery could join S Jax,, Laurent Robinson, Brandon Gibson, and Danny Amendola as an interesting offensive nucleus. Now about that quarterback situation?

54. Mohamed Massaquoi, Browns | Age: 23.10 – The second-rounder proved he could get open and make plays, but he's in desperate need of an accurate, strong-armed quarterback.

55. Davone Bess, Dolphins | Age: 25.0 – Not mucjh value in standard leagues because of his role in Miami‘s offense, but Bess has plenty of value in PPR leagues.

56. Mike Thomas, Jaguars | Age: 23.3 –Tory Holt’s 's decline will open a starting job in 2010, but do the Jags prefer to keep Thomas in the slot?

57. Mario Manningham, Giants | Age: 24.4 – Showed playmaking ability but lost his starting job to Hakeem Nicks late in the season.

58. Nate Burleson, Seahawks | Age: 29.1 – Is he a legit No. 1 receiver? Receivers with Burleson's questionable history of production can't afford to fade down the stretch.

59. Devery Henderson, Saints | Age: 28.6 – Boom-or-bust receivers make for a losing fantasy team over the course of the season.

60. Brandon Gibson, Rams | Age: 23.1 – Laurent Robinson may be the better talent and is likely to take his starting job back in 2010, but Gibson will contribute..

61. Chas Shilens, Raiders | Age: 24.10 – Another player to target in offseasons, Schilens is coming off a season lost to a foot fracture and poor quarterback play. Shilens has the talent - in Weeks 15 and 16 of the past two seasons combined, Schilens has racked up 18 catches for 261 yards and two TDs.

62. Greg Camarillo, Dolphins - Age 27.6 - Camarillo began the season coming off ACL surgery and struggled at the outset. The Dolphins’ rotation among all four of wideouts doen’t leave much room for fantasy production from anyone.

63. Josh Morgan, 49ers | Age: 25.3 - I'm still bullish on Morgan as player, but his fantasy value is limited behind Vernon Davis and Michael Crabtree.

64. Ted Ginn, Dolphins | Age: 25.5 – The Miami coaches keep sticking up for him, but they also seem to understand that he's best used as a situational deep threat. Look for the Dolphins to pursue a true No. 1 receiver this offseason.

Tier Seven
65. Deon Butler, Seahawks | Age: 24.8 – Butler has serious speed, and he should move ahead to take Branch’s job in 2010.

66. Jordy Nelson, Packers | Age: 25.4 – Nelson has flashed talent in the fourth receiver role in his first two seasons, but his value is capped by the presence of James Jones.

67. Andre “Bubba” Caldwell, Bengals | Age: 25.5 – Opportunity knocked in 2009, and Caldwell told it to away. His inability to make plays late in the season was telling.

68. Sammie Stroughter, Buccaneers - Age 24.5 - Stroughter ended his season on injured reserve with a broken foot. He's likely to be Tampa's long-term answer at slot receiver.

69. Danny Amendola, Rams, Age 24.7 - Amendola has set a Rams record with 1,643 total return yards. He also will have a chance to be the team's slot receiver in 2010.

70. Earl Bennett, Bears | Age: 23.6 – Average talent who works best in the slot and needs GPS to find the end zone.

71. Kevin Ogletree, Cowboys | Age: 23.1 – Could be starting alongside Miles Austin by 2011. For now, Roy Williams is standing in the way of his progress.

72. Brandon Tate, Patriots | Age: 22.11 - An explosive talent who should be fully recovered from his ACL injury this summer.

73. Jarrett Dillard, Jaguars | Age: 24.9 – Was just beginning to give Mike Thomas a run for his money as the No. 3 receiver before suffering a broken ankle.

Special Situations - Short Term Rental Value
74. Hines Ward, Steelers | Age: 34.6 – It's hard to ignore his production. At age 34, Ward still finished #16 among fantasy receivers despite the late-season hamstring woes.

75. Donald Driver, Packers | Age: 35.7 – Keeps himself in great shape, but he’s now the #3 option behind Jennings and Jermichael Finley.

76. Terrell Owens, Bills | Age: 36.8 – Clearly declining, but there's a possibility of a bounce-back fantasy season if he lands in the right situation with a good quarterback.

77. Chris Chambers, Chiefs | Age: 32.1 – Unrestricted free agent took advantage of Bowe's absence late in the season. Will he be back in K.C.?

78. Laveranues Coles, Bengals | Age: 32.7 – Can't be expected to better his mediocre 2009 numbers as he ages.

79. T J Houshmandzadeh, Seahawks | Age: 33.0 – Aging, overpaid possession receivers with no after-the-catch ability have to produce in the present to maintain value. Housh managed just two games over 80 yards all season.

80. Derrick Mason, Ravens | Age: 36.8 – Fantasy's No. 20 receiver in 2009, Mason says he will make a decision on his playing future "quickly and definitively." He would be ranked near the top of the “rentals”, but it is quite likely that he will retire.
 
TOP 55 DYNASTY RBs

Tier One
1. Chris Johnson, Titans | Age: 25.0 – A once a generation RB with his combination of sick speed, moves, and quick-cutting ability. The answer to the question of whether V Young would do more harm than good was answered definitively in the final 10 games. Despite the yards from scrimmage record and his 2009 rushing title at a whopping 582 more yards than his closest competitor, Johnson has gotten skepticism because of his body size. To set the record straight, many bigger backs have shorter careers than backs of Johnson's stature.

2. Adrian Peterson, Vikings | Age: 25.6 – You can't be faulted if you stick to your guns on ADP as the No. 1 back. While he saw a drop-off in attempts, yards, and YPC, he more than made up for it with a two-fold increase in receptions and a league-high 18 TDs. Could he put it all together in 2010? With all of the attention on his second-half slump and declining yards per carry, it went unnoticed that Peterson shattered his best fantasy season this year. His receptions have risen steadily from 19 to 21 to 42 – just four fewer than Chris Johnson (and eight fewer than Frank Gore and Steven Jackson).

3. Maurice Jones-Drew, Jaguars | Age: 25.6 – In his four-year career, MJD has averaged 14 TDs, 50 receptions, and 4.7 YPC mostly in part-time work. The focal point of the Jags offense, Jones-Drew's value is as safe as it gets.

4. Ray Rice, Ravens | Age: 23.8 – Drawing comparisons to a faster Emmitt Smith, Rice was the best receiving back in the league, an explosive runner, and a very good blocker. The hand-wringing over the lack of goal-line carries is reminiscent of Chris Johnson last season. Rice's 45 touchdowns in his last two seasons at Rutgers suggest he can handle the role just fine.

Tier Two
5. Jonathan Stewart, Panthers | Age: 23. 6 – He’s a physical freak whose talent alone would put him comfortably in the top tier. Has he made DeAngelo Williams expendable on the cap-strapped Panthers? It's a sentiment gaining steam of late, but the Panthers won’t easily part with impact players, especially one with a salary as low as Williams' $725K. Though DeWill isn't likely to depart this season, his contract is up in 2011.

6. DeAngelo Williams, Panthers | Age: 27.5 – It's not that Williams isn't one of the best backs in the league; he is. The problem is he's going to spend at least one more year in his prime splitting carries with J-Stew.

7. Frank Gore, 49ers | Age: 27.4 – Concerns about his injury history and workload in a potential spread offense are severely overblown. A do-everything back who finished fifth in fantasy points despite missing almost three full games, he actually bettered Ray Rice in points per week.

8. Steven Jackson, Rams | Age: 27.2 – S-Jax is the case for special talent as the trump card in Dynasty leagues. With a floor so high that he's producing quality numbers in a sunk offense, he's the perfect example of why studs have to be ranked highly regardless of situation. Remember that the next time somebody tells you that Calvin johnson isn't an elite dynasty receiver.

Tier Three
9. Jamaal Charles, Chiefs | Age: 23.9 - To quote Todd Haley: "We started by saying that this was a 15-carry per game guy. He's forced us to think differently about him." I'm trying to pick apart his game and his situation to find a major concern, but I've come up empty. Charles is a 23-year-old feature back with the second-most fantasy points over the second-half of the season on top of 5.9(!) YPC and natural pass-catching skills. What's not to like?

10. Rashard Mendenhall, Steelers | Age: 23.3 – Mendenhall's downhill, physical style is a natural fit for the Steelers offense, and he surprisingly pushed Mewelde Moore out of the third-down role down the stretch. He's an every-down back heading into a 2010 season in which the Steelers want to re-establish the running game.

11. Beanie Wells, Cardinals | Age: 22.1 - He ran like a man possessed over the second half of the season, punishing tacklers and refusing to go down on first contact. He's been described as 95 percent of Adrian Peterson, which isn't as ridiculous as it sounds at first blush.

12. Knowshon Moreno, Broncos | Age: 23.2 – Moreno is a chain-mover with impressive success rates and few negative plays. What killed his value was that defenses didn't respect the passing game and the offensive line fell apart. McDaniels is weeding out the Shanahan guys, so the offense will start to go through Moreno instead of Marshall. He won't always be paired with Buckhalter; so his production should be more consistent and his receptions will skyrocket. Expect borderline RB1 production for the next five years.

13. Michael Turner, Falcons | Age: 28.7 – Backs in their age-28 seasons usually receive a downgrade because most of their value is tied up in the past as opposed to the future. Turner can still put forth a dominant season in 2010, but is that worth giving up five years of production from a younger back?

14. Felix Jones, Cowboys | Age: 23.4 – Can the Cowboys really keep him on the bench after he showed what he could do with 15+ touches against the Eagles last week? Jones still has questions to answer about workload and fragility, but his playmaking ability makes him a fantasy asset with 12-15 touches per week.

15. Ahmad Bradshaw, Giants | Age: 24.6 – Built like a change of pace back, but runs like he's an iron head. Even with an injured foot (feet?), Bradshaw was far more effective than his backfield partner Brandon Jacobs.

Tier Four
16. Jerome Harrison, Browns | Age: 27.7 – He's a virtual lock to enter 2010 as the Browns' starter, but keep in mind that Harrison's amazing finish to the 2009 season came against the Chiefs, Raiders, and Jags defenses.

17.Shonn Greene, Jets | Age: 25.1 - Showed great short-area quickness and finished his runs with authority, pushing Thomas Jones to the side against the Bengals last week. Jones is expected to return to the Jets in 2010, so Greene may have to wait another year for weekly fantasy value.

18. Pierre Thomas, Saints | Age: 25.9 – . His effectiveness is undeniable. We'd all like to see Pierre used more often, but the root of the issue is that Sean Payton is convinced Thomas can't handle a full workload without getting nicked up.

19. Donald Brown, Colts | Age: 23.5 – His injury-plagued rookie season isn't going to have the Colts in a hurry to part ways with Addai. Brown will have to prove he can hold up as an NFL back before his workload increases.

20. LeSean McCoy, Eagles | Age: 22.2 - His rookie season was a mixed bag. When Westbrook first went down, McCoy was given the opportunity to take the job and run with it. Instead, he forced the coaches to work Leonard Weaver into the mix. While he's already an asset in PPR leagues, he may turn out to be more of a committee back instead of a Westbrook clone.

21. Darren Sproles, Chargers | Age: 27.3 – When he gets the ball in his hands, he flat-out produces fantasy points. while he Chargers' 2010 backfield is up in the air, it's easy to picture Sproles in a similar role to the one he's had the past two seasons, but with an increase in touches.

Tier Five
22. Ronnie Brown, Dolphins | Age: 28.9 – He remains one of the best all-around talents at the position, but he just can't stay healthy for a full season. Brown will be close to 29 years old and coming off another major injury going into next season. And Ricky Wiliams isn't going anywhere.

23. Ryan Grant, Packers | Age: 27.9 – Grant is a very good open-field runner who still struggles at times to read his blocks and should never be used in the passing game. Grant finished No. 8 in fantasy points on the season, slamming the door on speculation that his starting job is in jeopardy. The Packers' high-scoring offense gives him a value boost.

24. Cedric Benson, Bengals | Age: 27.9 - Bears fans can't believe it. The Cincinnati Benson bears little resemblance to the Chicago Benson, and he's running with authority and explosiveness behind a heavy workload. Benson is a free agent after next season.

25. Marion Barber, Cowboys | Age: 27.3 – Injuries adversely affected his production for the second straight year, enough so that felix Jones is threatening to take over as the feature back. Since signing his big-money deal, MBIII's per-carry average has dropped by half a yard, he's fumbling twice as often, and his TD percentage has been cut in half.

26. Darren McFadden, Raiders | Age: 23.1 - An injury-prone timeshare back in an offense held hostage by the quarterback, McFadden has left far too much yardage on the field the past two seasons. Now is the ideal time to buy low if you were ever a true believer.

27. Joseph Addai, Colts | Age: 27.4 – Addai has always been a player who derived too much value out of situation and not enough out of talent. That remains the case, and he stands to lose a lot of value through the 2010 season if Donald Brown can stay healthy.

28. Matt Forte, Bears | Age: 24.9 – Poor Forte received no help from his offensive line, but neither did Jamaal Charles. While Forte is solid across the board, there's just nothing special about his talent. No longer the offensive centerpiece, it's hard to consider him a nucleus player in Dynasty circles with a 3.6 YPC and major red-zone issues.

29. Fred Jackson, Bills | Age: 29.7 – The Bills offense simply runs better with Jackson as the main man. F-Jax is a superior receiver, arguably a more explosive runner, and does a fine job in short-yardage. If his new head coach decides to put production ahead of pedigree, F-Jax will remain the feature back.

30. Marshawn Lynch, Bills | Age: 24.5 - Dynasty owners didn't draft him to be a time-share back. In addition to his off-the field problems, Lynch has been out-produced by his backup for two straight seasons. I wouldn't want to count on the new coaching staff liking him better than F-Jax, especially since Jackson certainly appears to be the better player.

31. Brandon Jacobs, Giants | Age: 28.2 – Jacobs just isn't getting it done. There's no question that he was a slower, more plodding back in 2009, but his disappointing season also served as a useful reminder that bigger backs are much more reliant on their blocking. Jacobs' value is wrapped up in touchdowns, which is troublesome with Bradshaw out-producing him in the red zone. If you're not scared off by aging, injury-prone running backs who don't catch passes, buy low.

32. Reggie Bush, Saints | Age: 25.6 - Bush is a talented but injury-prone role player in the Saints offense. He could end up with more playing time outside of New Orleans, but how much value can he have without the ability or the willingness to run forward?

Tier Six
33. Michael Bush, Raiders | Age: 26.3 – The Raiders coaches have no idea how to evaluate running back talent. Despite being shoe-horned into a fullback role last season and neglected this season, Bush still has the three best rushing performances of the past year and a half. Bush owners should hope for achange of scenery or a coaching change.

34. Tashard Choice, Cowboys | Age: 25.10 – More effective than an injury-plagued Marion Barber for the second straight season.

35. Willis McGahee, Ravens | Age: 28.11 – Expected to be a cap casualty in Baltimore, and his Week 17 performance against the Raiders may have been enough to earn him the greater share of a committee job in 2010. He'll be bringing fresh legs wherever he lands.

36. Steve Slaton, Texans | Age: 24.8 - He is a passing-down, change-of-pace back masquerading as a lead back. Slaton could easily become a back in the vein of Willie Parker and Addai, where the coaches continue to take pieces of responsibility away from him until he's nothing more than complementary part. Such is the case in Houston, where the Texans are expected to add an early-down back early in this year's draft.

37. Chester Taylor, Vikings | Age: 31.0 – Taylor is due to hit unrestricted free agency at age 31. While he's obviously one of the top backups in the game, he's a long-shot to land his own starting gig in 2010.

38. Tim Hightower, Cardinals | Age: 24.4 - Was never a good bet to maintain value once the team drafted Beanie Wells, and he may be losing flex value as well. Has value as a role player who can catch the ball out of the backfield.

39. Laurance Maroney, Patriots | Age: 25.7 - Maroney had his final chance to be "the man" in New England, and he may have again fumbled it away. He's a committee back with an injury history, and a reputation for running east/west and for dancing at the line.

40. Thomas Jones, Jets | Age: 32.1 - The passing of the torch? Jones has been phenomenal the past two seasons, far surpassing expectations while laughing in the face of the age-30 running back decline. But Shonn Greene is coming like a freight train.

Tier Seven
41. Justin Forsett, Seahawks | Age: 24.11 – A very good NFL role player. But assuming he gets a shot at the lead-back job, he's not likely to hold onto it for multiple seasons.

42. Arian Foster, Texans | Age: 24.1 – He played well when given a shot at the starting job. He’s not a special talent, but Foster averaged nearly a full yard more per carry than Ryan Moats and a yard and a half more than Slaton. With nice hands and after-the-catch ability, he has a chance to become the starter in Kubiak's one-cut-and-go system.

43. Leon Washington, Jets | Age: 28.1 – He’d be ranked higher, but we don't know how much speed and cutting ability he left on the operating table after he suffered a double open fracture to his right leg.

44. Bernard Scott, Bengals | Age: 26.7 – Check out his age. Scott is an intriguing talent, but he's already 26 years old and sitting behind a better back in Benson.

45-46-47-48-49 . D J Ware, Giants; Jalen Parmele, Baltimore; Jason Snelling, Atlanta; Rashd Jennings, Jacksonville; Aaron Brown, Detroit - All young guys who have decent talent and are in a position to be primary baack-ups in 2010.

Special Situation - Potential Short-term Rentals
50. Cadillac Williams, Buccaneers | Age: 28.5 – Caddy may have been deserving of the Comeback Player of the Year award, but his fantasy ceiling is limited by the Bucs' rotation. In spite of his significant injury history, he may have a few productive years left.

51. Brian Westbrook, Eagles | Age: 31.0 - The Eagles will likely bring him back at a reduced salary. Westbrook can still play effectively, but the Eagles' reluctance to use him in the playoff loss raises questions.

52. Ricky Williams, Dolphins | Age: 33.3 - The most interesting character in the NFL over the past decade. Who knows what he has in store for his next act in 2010?

53. Ladainian Tomlinson, Chargers | Age: 31.3 - The trademark explosiveness is gone. You can forget about the retirement talk, but LT is likely playing out his last San Diego hurrah over the next few weeks. Where he lands in 2010 in anyone's guess.

54. Clinton Portis, Redskins | Age: 29.0 - Running on empty. Portis can't stay on the field, he's ineffective when he does play. and his work ethic is being called into question.

Special Situation - High Risk

55. Kevin Smith, Lions | Age: 23.9 - Smith proved that his toughness was beyond question in playing through a shoulder separation, before his gruesome knee injury. With every ligament completely torn in his knee, he's unlikely to play effectively in the 2010 season. But given his youth and talent, don’t write him off completely.

TOP 29 DYNASTY QBs (it was 30 before Kurt Warner retired):

Tier One
1. Aaron Rodgers, Packers | Age: 26.9 – Five years younger than Brees, eight years younger than Manning, and already outproducing both with just as many weapons. The best playmaking QB in the league.

2. Drew Brees, Saints | Age: 31.8 – The most accurate QB in the game, Brees enjoys a domefield advantage and has plenty of weapons plus a creative playcaller.

3. Peyton Manning, Colts | Age: 34.6 – You can set your watch by Manning finishing in the Top-5. The emergence of Garcon and Collie to go with Wayne, Clark and wildcard Gonzalez maintains stability for future years.

4. Philip Rivers, Chargers | Age: 28.9 – The Chargers have morphed into a pass-first offense behind the All-Pro caliber play of Rivers, V-Jax, and Gates. Rivers is the best in the league at throwing past the sticks on third down.

5. Matt Schaub, Texans | Age: 29.3 – May be missing the "it" factor, but he can put up elite numbers.

Tier Two
6. Matt Ryan, Falcons | Age: 25.4 – The No. 1 QB buy of the upcoming offseason, Ryan's 2009 metrics in a "disappointing" season suggest he remains a rising star.

7. Ben Roethlisberger, Steelers | Age: 28.6 – If not for the concussion history and the uncertain future of coordinator Bruce Arians, Big Ben would be in the big tent with the fantasy masters. He's certainly in the conversation for best NFL QB.

8. Tony Romo, Cowboys | Age: 30.5 – Miles Austin’s emergence as a true playmaking No. 1 has Romo on the rise again

9. Tom Brady, Patriots | Age: 33.1 - Will be another year removed from knee surgery next year, but he's suddenly in dire need of an influx of offensive weapons at age 33.

10. Joe Flacco, Ravens | Age: 25.8 – The fantasy success hasn't arrived yet, but it's on the way. Flacco's 6,584 passing yards through his first two seasons are the fifth-most in NFL history.

11. Jay Cutler, Bears | Age: 27.5 – Million-dollar arm, five-cent head, but the Bears offense has nowhere to go but up in 2010. Cutler should be a good buy-low.

Tier Three
12. Vince Young, Titans | Age: 27.4 – The comeback from the brink of a wasted career was surprising enough, but an even more shocking development occurred when Young brought the deep ball back in Tennessee. While he still needs work on his mechanics and accuracy, VY's second term has much more explosive offensive talent.

13. Matthew Stafford, Lions | Age: 22.7 – Stafford took a beating in his rookie season, but he earned the respect of his coaches and teammates as a team leader with a cannon arm, toughness, and poise. An upgraded offensive line and legit No. 2 receiver would do wonders for his production.

14. Mark Sanchez, Jets | Age: 23.10 - Coordinator Brian Schottenheimer is talking up a recent "transformation" in his rookie QB, and Sanchez gets credit for his best performance in the biggest game of the year. He has the confidence, toughness, and intelligence to be a true building block.

15. Eli Manning, Giants | Age: 29.8 – Career year in 2009 with the influx of young receiving talent. Can he stay above 60 percent on completions and avoid the late-season doldrums?

16. Donavan McNabb, Eagles | Age: 33.10 – Aging, streaky QB with explosive young weapons in the passing game and an annoying habit of losing accuracy for stretches. Another extension in Philly would be nice.

Tier Four
17. Chad Henne, Dolphins | Age: 25.2 – Henne struggled with ill-timed interceptions, a below average feel for the pass rush, and inconsistent accuracy in his 13 starts. On the flip side, he has the arm, the intangibles, and the penchant for rising to the occasion.

18. Josh Freeman, Buccaneers | Age: 22.8 – The athleticism and arm strength were expected, but Freeman also showed surprising accuracy. If he can learn to hold onto the ball, he may survive the lack of surrounding talent.

19. Kevin Kolb, Eagles | Age: 26.1 – How long until he gets his shot? Kolb was better than expected in two early-season starts, but it's worth pointing out that his numbers were padded in garbage time against the Saints while DeSean Jackson did the heavy lifting against a decrepit Chiefs defense.

20. Matt Moore, Panthers | Age: 26.1 – If only he had a started for the Panthers all year. The coaching staff finally began trusting Moore down the stretch, and he rewarded them with an impressive 4-1 finish. Now 7-3 as a starter, Moore is the favorite to enter 2010 as Carolina's quarterback.

21. Jason Campbell, Redskins | Age: 28.9 – Would like to see what he could do with a fresh start behind a solid offensive line and 2-3 years in the same offensive system. Statistically, he's coming off the best season of his career when everything crumpled around him.

Tier Five

22. Carson Palmer, Bengals | Age: 30.8 – Bypassed Eli Manning as the most over-rated player in the league in 2009. Whether it's an arm injury or simply a mechanical issue, he's morphed into a less accurate Chad Pennington.

23. Michael Vick, Eagles | Age: 30.3 – There’s a decent chance he has his own starting job in 2010. How much is left of the pre-prison magic?

24. Matt Cassel, Chiefs | Age: 28.4 – A bust in his first season as the Chiefs' franchise quarterback, Cassel has reason for hope with offensive cornerstones Jamaal charles and Dwayne Bowe. Improvement up front is a must.

25. Kyle Orton, Broncos | Age: 27.10 – Having Orton as your starting quarterback is the NFL equivalent of purgatory. The Broncos are biding their time until something better comes along.

26. Alex Smith, 49ers | Age: 26.4 – Despite intermittent progress in the second half, the 49ers are kidding themselves if they believe they can seriously contend with Smith at QB.

27. Matt Leinart, Cardinals | Age: 27.4 – His work in relief of Warner the past few seasons hasn't exactly inspired confidence. The Cardinals may seek competition for Leinart if Warner retires.

28. Nate Davis, 49ers | Age: 23.4 – Outplayed Alex smith and Shaun Hill in preseason action last summer. Unless the Niners draft a QB this April, there's more chaff than wheat in front of him in SF.

Special Possible One Year Rental
29. Brett Favre, Vikings | Age: 40.11 – Coming off arguably the most impressive regular season of his career, Favre is enjoying more playmaking offensive weapons than he's ever had at his disposal. Why retire now?

I only posted 194 rankings and it would be fun to see the list expanded to be an even 200. I'd appreciate your comments on the listing as a whole, and would be interested to see who you would recommend for the final 6 players in the top 200.
 
nice list.

If I am drafting in a new dynasty league, sorry, there is still no way I'm taking Finley #1....that is ascending him just a bit early IMO.

DJax and Miles seem high, not sure I place eithe rin the top 5.

I would still put Cal Johnson in my top 3 WR's. Brandon Marshall would be in my top 5 as well, don't care where he is at.

Greg Jennings is too low. Bowe is too low as well, Mike Wallace too high, need to see him a bit more before I consider him that high.

Tier 1 RB's are on the money

Jon Stewart is WAY too high.....just don't see him holding up, too many concerns.

9-12 is 4 interesting prospects, all VERY young, all great potential. If you are starting a dynasty and they are your 1st or 2nd pick, they could also all cripple you.

Greene is too low, deserves to be in that group above.

Benson a little low.

Fred Jackson is a steal where he is at....Matt Forte, wow has the mighty rook fallen.

Just some random thoughts.
 
-I too felt Miles was way too high, and agree on Finley, though I do see him as a top 5.
- I felt Heath Miller was plenty low
-I feel Gonzo is still a top 5-7 TE
-I move reggie and Jennings up, and Miles and DeSean down. Miles much further down than deSean who is a valid top 8.
-The top teir in WR is too deep. It should end at 3, but i like Wayne over Calvin.
-Boldin needs to climb
-Stewart is way to high, and Shonn greene needs to move up.
- Benson and grant need to move up
 
Amazing what a difference a year makes. Forte was probably a top 3-5 dynasty RB last year. Sitting at 28 this year (one mans opinion I realize). Comments pretty much say it all. No longer the center piece of the offense and just nothing special about his talent.
 
Back
Top